M-Dollar 143 Posted December 14, 2017 Share Posted December 14, 2017 woow, i have never seen this But that could also be a proof for a mic error. Maybe somebody forgot to turn her mic off. It seems weird to me that in every show her vocoder screaming like "Whats up xxx" "are you ready" "dont fuck with the queen" sounded always pretty messy, and overloaded with vocoder, but her revolver singing, suddenly, is just perfect.... still think it was playback Who knows, but she didn't use the vocoder when she talked in the intro of Revolver during the first shows. She started with that later if I remember it right. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Roy 7,610 Posted December 14, 2017 Share Posted December 14, 2017 woow, i have never seen this But that could also be a proof for a mic error. Maybe somebody forgot to turn her mic off. It seems weird to me that in every show her vocoder screaming like "Whats up xxx" "are you ready" "dont fuck with the queen" sounded always pretty messy, and overloaded with vocoder, but her revolver singing, suddenly, is just perfect.... still think it was playback She did lipsync in Revolver. Here's a clip from St. Petersburg. She forgot that she's going to start the first verse. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Roy 7,610 Posted December 14, 2017 Share Posted December 14, 2017 The MDNA Tour (2012) Girl Gone Wild (Lip Synched) Revolver (Live on the Shoutout with the Vocoder, Lip Synched on the entire song) Gang Bang (Lip Synched; Monologue Ending Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) Hung Up (Lip Synched) Express Yourself (Sung Live) Give Me All Your Luvin' (Lip Synched) Turn Up the Radio (Sung Live) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Masterpiece (Sung Live) Vogue (Lip Synched) Erotic Candy Shop (Sung Live on some dates, Lipped on other dates) Human Nature (Sung Live) Like a Virgin Waltz (Sung Live) Love Spent (Sung Live) I'm Addicted (Sung Live) I'm A Sinner (Lip Synched) Like a Prayer (Sung Live) Celebration (Lip Synched) I If we are going to be that petty, we should add that not just the ending, but also the start of Gang Bang was sung live. As proof for that we got the Voice Mixdown. Playback starts at "I tought it was you..." For Celebration, the start was live and playback started at "Put your arms around me.." Also I would like to add that I love the fact, that she uses pre-recorded live vocals, instead of the Original Studio Version, like some other Pop star starting with "Bri" and ending with "ears" :) :) :) Shade~ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bat-Fan 1,167 Posted December 19, 2017 Share Posted December 19, 2017 Let me try to fix the list. XD The Virgin Tour (1985) Dress You Up (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Sung Live) Everybody (Sung Live) Angel (Sung Live) Gambler (Sung Live) Borderline (Sung Live) Lucky Star (Sung Live) Crazy for You (Sung Live) Over and Over (Sung Live) Burning Up (Sung Live) Like a Virgin/Billie Jean (Sung Live) Material Girl (Sung Live) Who's That Girl World Tour (1987) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Lucky Star (Sung Live) True Blue (Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) White Heat (Sung Live) Causing a Commotion (Sung Live) The Look of Love (Sung Live) Dress You Up/Material Girl/Like a Virgin (Sung Live) Where's the Party (Sung Live) Live to Tell (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Who's That Girl (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live) Blond Ambition World Tour (1990) Express Yourself (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Causing a Commotion (Sung Live) Where's the Party (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) *The Performance in Nice and Barcelona proves that you can still hear her live vocals.* Like a Virgin (Sung Live) Like a Prayer (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Live to Tell/Oh Father (Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) Sooner or Later (Sung Live) Hanky Panky (Sung Live) Now I'm Following You (Intentionally Lip Synched) Material Girl (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance on Chorus) Cherish (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Holiday (Sung Live) Keep It Together (Sung Live) The Girlie Show Tour (1993) Erotica (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Fever (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Rain (Sung Live) Express Yourself (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance on Chorus) Deeper and Deeper (Sung Live) Why's It So Hard (Sung Live) In This Life (Sung Live) Like a Virgin (Sung Live) Bye Bye Baby (Sung Live on some parts, Partially Lipped on the Chorus) I'm Going Bananas (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live) Justify My Love (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance, Live on the Final Part) Everybody Is a Star/Everybody (Sung Live) Drowned World Tour (2001) Drowned World/Substitute for Love (Sung Live) Impressive Instant (Sung Live) Candy Perfume Girl (Sung Live) Beautiful Stranger (Sung Live) Ray of Light (Sung Live) Frozen (Sung Live) Open Your Heart Swell/Nobody's Perfect (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Mer Girl I/Sky Fits Heaven/Mer Girl II (Sung Live, Lip Synched, Sung Live) I Deserve It (Sung Live) Don't Tell Me (Sung Live) Human Nature (Sung Live) The Funny Song (Sung Live) Secret (Sung Live) Gone (Sung Live) Lo Que Siente La Mujer (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Music (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Re-Invention World Tour (2004) Vogue (Lip Synched) Nobody Knows Me (Lip Synched) Frozen (Sung Live) American Life (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance; Rap Lip Synched) Express Yourself (Sung Live With Backing Track Assistance) Burning Up (Sung Live) Material Girl (Sung Live) Hanky Panky (Sung Live) Deeper and Deeper (Sung Live) Die Another Day (Lip Synched) Lament (Sung Live) Nothing Fails (Sung Live) Don't Tell Me (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Like a Prayer (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Mother and Father (Sung Live) Imagine (Sung Live) ​Into the Groove (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance, Lipped on the last few dates of the tour) Crazy for You (Sung Live) Music (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Holiday (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Confessions Tour (2006) Future Lovers/I Feel Love (Future Lovers Sung Live; I Feel Love Lip Synched but Sung Live in the opening concert) Get Together (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Like a Virgin (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Jump (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Live to Tell (Sung Live) Forbidden Love (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Isaac (Sung Live) Sorry (Lip Synched) Like it Or Not (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) I Love New York (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Ray of Light (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Let it Will Be (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Drowned World/Substitute for Love (Sung Live) Paradise (Not For Me) (Sung Live) Music Inferno (Lip Synched) Erotica (Lip Synched) La Isla Bonita (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Lucky Star (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Hung Up (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Sticky and Sweet Tour (2008/2009) 2008: Candy Shop (Lip Synched) Beat Goes On (Lip Synched) Human Nature (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Lip Synched) Heartbeat (Lip Synched) Borderline (Sung Live) She's Not Me (Sung Live) Music (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Devil Wouldn't Recognize You (Lip Synched) Spanish Lesson (Sung Live) Miles Away (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) You Must Love Me (Sung Live) 4 Minutes (Lip Synched) Like a Payer (Sung Live) Ray of Light (Sung Live) Hung Up (Sung Live) Give It 2 Me (Lip Synched) 2009: Candy Shop (Lip Synched) Beat Goes On (Lip Synched) Human Nature (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Lip Synched) Holiday (Sung Live) Dress You Up (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) She's Not Me (Sung Live) Music (Lip Synched) Devil Wouldn't Recognize You (Lip Synched) Spanish Lesson (Sung Live) Miles Away (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) You Must Love Me (Sung Live) 4 Minutes (Lip Synched) Like a Prayer (Sung Live) Frozen (Lip Synched) ​Ray of Light (Sung Live) Give It 2 Me (Lip Synched) The MDNA Tour (2012) Girl Gone Wild (Lip Synched) Revolver (Live on the Shoutout with the Vocoder, Lip Synched on the entire song) Gang Bang (Lip Synched; Monologue Ending Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) Hung Up (Lip Synched) Express Yourself (Sung Live) Give Me All Your Luvin' (Lip Synched) Turn Up the Radio (Sung Live) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Masterpiece (Sung Live) Vogue (Lip Synched) Erotic Candy Shop (Sung Live on some dates, Lipped on other dates) Human Nature (Sung Live) Like a Virgin Waltz (Sung Live) Love Spent (Sung Live) I'm Addicted (Sung Live) I'm A Sinner (Lip Synched) Like a Prayer (Sung Live) Celebration (Lip Synched) Rebel Heart Tour (2015/2016) Iconic (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Bitch I'm Madonna (Sung Live with Vocoder) Burning Up (Sung Live) Holy Water/Vogue (Partially Live, Partially Lipped) Devil Pray (Lip Synched) Body Shop (Sung Live with Vocoder) Deeper and Deeper (Sung Live) HeartBreakCity/LDLHAM (Verses Live; Chorus Lip Synched; LDLHAM Sung Live) Like a Virgin (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Living for Love (Lip Synched) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Gypsy Medley (Sung Live) ​Who's That Girl (Sung Live) ALL Special Songs (Sung Live) Rebel Heart (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Music (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Candy Shop (Lip Synched) Material Girl (Sung Live) La Vie En Rose (Sung Live) Unapologetic Bitch (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Holiday (Sung Live) ufff your list is so wrong, where do begin... Well I will begin with pada dont preach is not sung live on bat tour, well it is but the chorus and bridge is 100% mimed Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
luckystar908 3,053 Posted December 19, 2017 Share Posted December 19, 2017 I'm not sure she did lip synched in Revolver. What about the show in Rome when the vocoder didn't start in the begining of the song? It did start, she's just singing over it. It's playback. The audience greeting with vocoder started in Barcelona, 2nd night. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
scion 3,107 Posted December 22, 2017 Share Posted December 22, 2017 Okay I'm sorry but that list (in the nicest way possible) is a crock of shite. I can't believe I'm doing this, but to be honest, I've nothing to do this morning... so let me give you a correct list, from somebody with a pretty sharp ear for layers in live music. The Virgin Tour: Sung Totally Live Who's That Girl Tour: Sung Totally Live (I've heard rumours previously that backing tracks were used, it's incorrect). Blond Ambition Tour: Express Yourself - Live over a backing track some shows, mimed on others. Open Your Heart - Live, the pre-chorus and chorus has a backing track underneath.Causing A Commotion - Live, the pre-chorus and chorus has a backing track underneath.Where’s The Party - Generally lip synched, live on some shows over a track. Like A Virgin - Live Like A Prayer - Live. There are taped elements under the live vocals in places eg. Nicki's solo.Medley: Live To Tell / Oh Father - LivePapa Don’t Preach - Live, the pre-chorus and chorus has a backing track underneath (it was NEVER lip synched). Sooner Or Later - Live Hanky Panky - LiveNow I’m Following You - Self explanatory. Material Girl - Live, chorus has a backing track underneath.Cherish Live - the pre-chorus and chorus has a backing track underneath.Into The Groove - Live, the pre-chorus and chorus has a backing track underneath.Vogue - Generally lip synched. Live vocals on some shows.Holiday - LiveKeep It Together - Live The Girlie Show Erotica - Lip synched. A few shows have the occasional live vocal. ​Fever - Live some nights, mimed on others. Vogue - As above, generally lip synched. Rain - Live Express Yourself - Live, backing track in chorus. Deeper and Deeper - Live Why's It So Hard - Live In This Live - Live Like a Virgin - Live Bye Bye Baby - Lip synched mostly I'm Going Banans - Waste of time La Isla Bonita - Live Holiday - Live Justify My Love - Lip synched except the last 30 seconds or so, NOT sung live over the track. Everybody - Live (backing track at Wembley if I recall correctly). Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
scion 3,107 Posted December 22, 2017 Share Posted December 22, 2017 Drowned World Tour: Generally live. Ray of Light and Music lipped in Barcelona for one show only. Sky Fits Heaven mimed always. NO songs were sung live over a backing track. What you hear is pre-recorded backing vocals and Donna&Nikki. There are NO backing lead vocals eg. from CT onwards. Re-Invention Tour: As above, all LIVE songs were sung live without lead vocal assistance. There was literally NO lead backing tape on most songs. The only songs lip synched were, Vogue, Nobody Knows Me, American Life (partially), Die Another Day,Papa Don't Preach and Into The Groove (most shows). The rest were totally live, no backing tracks, as the Lisbon show attests to. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Roy 7,610 Posted February 18, 2018 Share Posted February 18, 2018 On 12/19/2017 at 2:34 AM, Bat-Fan said: On 12/10/2017 at 1:06 PM, KaitoXD said: Let me try to fix the list. XD The Virgin Tour (1985) Dress You Up (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Sung Live) Everybody (Sung Live) Angel (Sung Live) Gambler (Sung Live) Borderline (Sung Live) Lucky Star (Sung Live) Crazy for You (Sung Live) Over and Over (Sung Live) Burning Up (Sung Live) Like a Virgin/Billie Jean (Sung Live) Material Girl (Sung Live) Who's That Girl World Tour (1987) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Lucky Star (Sung Live) True Blue (Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) White Heat (Sung Live) Causing a Commotion (Sung Live) The Look of Love (Sung Live) Dress You Up/Material Girl/Like a Virgin (Sung Live) Where's the Party (Sung Live) Live to Tell (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Who's That Girl (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live) Blond Ambition World Tour (1990) Express Yourself (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Causing a Commotion (Sung Live) Where's the Party (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) *The Performance in Nice and Barcelona proves that you can still hear her live vocals.* Like a Virgin (Sung Live) Like a Prayer (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Live to Tell/Oh Father (Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) Sooner or Later (Sung Live) Hanky Panky (Sung Live) Now I'm Following You (Intentionally Lip Synched) Material Girl (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance on Chorus) Cherish (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Holiday (Sung Live) Keep It Together (Sung Live) The Girlie Show Tour (1993) Erotica (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Fever (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Rain (Sung Live) Express Yourself (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance on Chorus) Deeper and Deeper (Sung Live) Why's It So Hard (Sung Live) In This Life (Sung Live) Like a Virgin (Sung Live) Bye Bye Baby (Sung Live on some parts, Partially Lipped on the Chorus) I'm Going Bananas (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live) Justify My Love (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance, Live on the Final Part) Everybody Is a Star/Everybody (Sung Live) Drowned World Tour (2001) Drowned World/Substitute for Love (Sung Live) Impressive Instant (Sung Live) Candy Perfume Girl (Sung Live) Beautiful Stranger (Sung Live) Ray of Light (Sung Live) Frozen (Sung Live) Open Your Heart Swell/Nobody's Perfect (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Mer Girl I/Sky Fits Heaven/Mer Girl II (Sung Live, Lip Synched, Sung Live) I Deserve It (Sung Live) Don't Tell Me (Sung Live) Human Nature (Sung Live) The Funny Song (Sung Live) Secret (Sung Live) Gone (Sung Live) Lo Que Siente La Mujer (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Holiday (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Music (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Re-Invention World Tour (2004) Vogue (Lip Synched) Nobody Knows Me (Lip Synched) Frozen (Sung Live) American Life (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance; Rap Lip Synched) Express Yourself (Sung Live With Backing Track Assistance) Burning Up (Sung Live) Material Girl (Sung Live) Hanky Panky (Sung Live) Deeper and Deeper (Sung Live) Die Another Day (Lip Synched) Lament (Sung Live) Nothing Fails (Sung Live) Don't Tell Me (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Like a Prayer (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Mother and Father (Sung Live) Imagine (Sung Live) ​Into the Groove (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance, Lipped on the last few dates of the tour) Crazy for You (Sung Live) Music (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Holiday (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Confessions Tour (2006) Future Lovers/I Feel Love (Future Lovers Sung Live; I Feel Love Lip Synched but Sung Live in the opening concert) Get Together (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Like a Virgin (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Jump (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Live to Tell (Sung Live) Forbidden Love (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Isaac (Sung Live) Sorry (Lip Synched) Like it Or Not (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) I Love New York (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Ray of Light (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Let it Will Be (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Drowned World/Substitute for Love (Sung Live) Paradise (Not For Me) (Sung Live) Music Inferno (Lip Synched) Erotica (Lip Synched) La Isla Bonita (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Lucky Star (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Hung Up (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Sticky and Sweet Tour (2008/2009) 2008: Candy Shop (Lip Synched) Beat Goes On (Lip Synched) Human Nature (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Lip Synched) Heartbeat (Lip Synched) Borderline (Sung Live) She's Not Me (Sung Live) Music (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Devil Wouldn't Recognize You (Lip Synched) Spanish Lesson (Sung Live) Miles Away (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) You Must Love Me (Sung Live) 4 Minutes (Lip Synched) Like a Payer (Sung Live) Ray of Light (Sung Live) Hung Up (Sung Live) Give It 2 Me (Lip Synched) 2009: Candy Shop (Lip Synched) Beat Goes On (Lip Synched) Human Nature (Sung Live) Vogue (Sung Live) Into the Groove (Lip Synched) Holiday (Sung Live) Dress You Up (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) She's Not Me (Sung Live) Music (Lip Synched) Devil Wouldn't Recognize You (Lip Synched) Spanish Lesson (Sung Live) Miles Away (Sung Live) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) You Must Love Me (Sung Live) 4 Minutes (Lip Synched) Like a Prayer (Sung Live) Frozen (Lip Synched) ​Ray of Light (Sung Live) Give It 2 Me (Lip Synched) The MDNA Tour (2012) Girl Gone Wild (Lip Synched) Revolver (Live on the Shoutout with the Vocoder, Lip Synched on the entire song) Gang Bang (Lip Synched; Monologue Ending Sung Live) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live) Hung Up (Lip Synched) Express Yourself (Sung Live) Give Me All Your Luvin' (Lip Synched) Turn Up the Radio (Sung Live) Open Your Heart (Sung Live) Masterpiece (Sung Live) Vogue (Lip Synched) Erotic Candy Shop (Sung Live on some dates, Lipped on other dates) Human Nature (Sung Live) Like a Virgin Waltz (Sung Live) Love Spent (Sung Live) I'm Addicted (Sung Live) I'm A Sinner (Lip Synched) Like a Prayer (Sung Live) Celebration (Lip Synched) Rebel Heart Tour (2015/2016) Iconic (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Bitch I'm Madonna (Sung Live with Vocoder) Burning Up (Sung Live) Holy Water/Vogue (Partially Live, Partially Lipped) Devil Pray (Lip Synched) Body Shop (Sung Live with Vocoder) Deeper and Deeper (Sung Live) HeartBreakCity/LDLHAM (Verses Live; Chorus Lip Synched; LDLHAM Sung Live) Like a Virgin (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Living for Love (Lip Synched) La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Gypsy Medley (Sung Live) ​Who's That Girl (Sung Live) ALL Special Songs (Sung Live) Rebel Heart (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Music (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Candy Shop (Lip Synched) Material Girl (Sung Live) La Vie En Rose (Sung Live) Unapologetic Bitch (Partially Live; Partially Lipped) Holiday (Sung Live) ufff your list is so wrong, where do begin... Well I will begin with pada dont preach is not sung live on bat tour, well it is but the chorus and bridge is 100% mimed Yeah, I just figured that out now as I compared the Yokohama, Barcelona and the Nice performance of it. She did mime it partially in the chorus and bridge especially in parts wherein she cannot reach well due to her throat infection. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kesiak 3,032 Posted March 4, 2018 Share Posted March 4, 2018 On 22/12/2017 at 11:01 AM, scion said: Okay I'm sorry but that list (in the nicest way possible) is a crock of shite. I can't believe I'm doing this, but to be honest, I've nothing to do this morning... so let me give you a correct list, from somebody with a pretty sharp ear for layers in live music. The Virgin Tour: Sung Totally Live 1 You can clearly hear backing track in the choruses and bridge of "Into The Groove" on all of the soundboard recordings from Virgin Tour. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
scion 3,107 Posted March 13, 2018 Share Posted March 13, 2018 Yes, but she's not miming, she's singing live over it, and very, very loudly. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Enrico 15,786 Posted March 31, 2018 Share Posted March 31, 2018 On 22/3/2018 at 2:23 PM, ulisan543 said: Wow.. I thought Vogue from the RIT was live. I really loved that bersion.... Is the Greta garbo part live though??? Because to me it has a different singing way. It has been resung in studio! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jeroenbloeming 17 Posted December 8, 2018 Share Posted December 8, 2018 She's Not Me was lip synced Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
VanP92 0 Posted December 30, 2018 Share Posted December 30, 2018 On 7/21/2016 at 12:49 PM, Enrico said: I was talking to some friends yesterday, they are musical theatre performers and we were watching Express Yourself from BAT and they said no one would be able to sing this song live with such dance routine!! Actually, there's footage of her rehearsing "Express yourself" with live vocals on youtube.. wondering why she choose to lypsynch Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rebel Hugo 16,982 Posted April 23, 2020 Share Posted April 23, 2020 On 12/30/2018 at 4:53 PM, VanP92 said: Actually, there's footage of her rehearsing "Express yourself" with live vocals on youtube.. wondering why she choose to lypsynch And the opening BAT show in Tokyo she sung Express Yourself live. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rebel Hugo 16,982 Posted April 23, 2020 Share Posted April 23, 2020 Can we talk about Madame X Tour? God Control (Sung Live with Vocoder) Dark Ballet (Partially Live, Partially Lipped) Human Nature (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistance) Vogue (Partially Live, Partially Lipped) I Don't Search I Find (Sung Live with Vocoder) Papa Don't Preach (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) American Life (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) Batuka (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) Fado Pechincha (Sung Live) Killers Who Are Partying (Partially Live, Partially Lipped) Crazy (Sung Live) Welcome to My Fado Club / La Isla Bonita (Sung Live) Sodade (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) Medellín (Sung Live with Vocoder) Extreme Occident (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) Frozen (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) Come Alive (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) Future (Sung Live with Vocoder) Crave (Sung Live) Like a Prayer (Sung Live with Backing Track Assistence) I Rise (Partially Live, Partially Lipped) Roy and groovyguy 1 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MandyLePumpum 195 Posted May 17, 2020 Share Posted May 17, 2020 Shouldn't we do a topic for each tour separately? God Control: the whispered vocals are playback. I think there's also a backing track in 'Crazy': the vocals are simply too fast to keep up with (the bits before and after 'shame on you'. I also think the amount of backing track might vary from night to night. At the Lisbon opening night, the backing tracks were really loud and I had a hard time hearing her live vocal. On subsequent nights, her live vocal was very prominent in the mix. Still, if her microphone were off for the entire show, I doubt there would be many instrumental parts. Then there's autotune, but I couldn't tell when it's used and when not. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Curtains 13,238 Posted January 12, 2022 Share Posted January 12, 2022 EDIT: You'll find my corrected and hopefully definitive list on page 4. Ivan Z 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mirtillo 1,755 Posted January 20, 2022 Share Posted January 20, 2022 On 12/8/2018 at 3:38 PM, jeroenbloeming said: She's Not Me was lip synced Is live. In Paris she forgotten a few lyrics. Curtains 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mirtillo 1,755 Posted January 20, 2022 Share Posted January 20, 2022 I'm a sinner is live. Guys come on! Curtains 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mirtillo 1,755 Posted January 20, 2022 Share Posted January 20, 2022 Justify my love Final is live. Justify, justify babe, justify my love, my loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee Curtains 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
beautifulkiller 682 Posted January 20, 2022 Share Posted January 20, 2022 she just records live sounding vocals most of the time that back her up when its required if she is not up to it etc ..i dont think singing live on so many shows is good for your voice ..hello sticky and sweet ...lol she is good at miming so i do not mind it .its not like britiney spears kind of lip sync no offence to her - i think this is one of the reasons she likes candy shop ..she feels at ease singing it live lol - touring really fucks up her voice ive noticed recently that she may even lipsync sometimes on the blonde ambition tour - like i said she is very good at it so its hard to try and figure it out Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
beautifulkiller 682 Posted January 20, 2022 Share Posted January 20, 2022 42 minutes ago, mirtillo said: I'm a sinner is live. Guys come on! yeah i think its live but with a very strong backing vocal - she tends to mime a lot when moving or dancing - when sitting or standing still she will sing live Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Curtains 13,238 Posted February 10, 2022 Share Posted February 10, 2022 Edited my post above because after rewatching many Blond Ambition shows it seems clear to me that Papa Don’t Preach was fully live at the first few dates of the tour (coinciding with when Express Yourself was live with a backing track until the Chicago show) and then the first two pre-choruses and choruses were lipped for the rest of the tour. This is pretty evident on the New Jersey recording of the show, where the volume of the vocals changes between the times where she lips and when she actually sings. Compare these « lower volume vocals » with the ones from the later dates of the tour and you’ll see that they were identical. Ziploc 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Régine Filange 2,582 Posted February 19, 2022 Share Posted February 19, 2022 i thought vogue from s&s was lip sync cuz the released version has "fix" the vocals to sound better, but i watched a fan video recently and she was singing live, i didnt expect it Curtains 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Curtains 13,238 Posted February 20, 2022 Share Posted February 20, 2022 19 hours ago, Régine Filange said: i thought vogue from s&s was lip sync cuz the released version has "fix" the vocals to sound better, but i watched a fan video recently and she was singing live, i didnt expect it The released version has fixed vocals for all the songs though. The large majority of the vocals were overdubbed with pre-recorded vocals. You Must Love Me, Don't Cry for Me Argentina, Like a Virgin and Hung Up were only pitch-corrected and are the most live sounding tracks on this release. The rap of Vogue was still always lipped. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.