Music Videos - Vevo vs, Retail VOB's

[gb.bruck 63]

So, people are uploading the vevo videos, but are they the best? So i decided to create this comparisson thread! So, here's a few facts before we start:

 

x Vevo videos are all upscaled to 1080p (they're not real 1080p!)

x Vevo videos are overcropped (so, you're not getting the full image)

x Vevo videos are all in 25fps (a lot of her videos are 23,976fps, so there is a lot of duplicated frames)

 

So, i'm not saying they'll always be worst, but we need to compare sources before deciding which ones to keep, since a lot of the DVDRetail's also have problems!

 

x VOB's of Celebration have bad quality

x Videos originally in PAL released only in NTSC

x Color problems (in the Immaculate Collection vobs)

 

[some of the problems quoted above about the vobs, are fixable! But not from vevo :/ ]

 

So, let's start!

(I didn't do them all at once, i'll be updtading this thread untill i compare all videos, and feel free to give your opinion)

 

Luckystar: http://www.imagebam.com/gallery/20fgjtoozzphndsi7wwmjibhlcqpq2ut

Borderline: http://www.imagebam.com/gallery/fmnjt3565ltxp0fo8zkuvn4hvmo9rtt7

Crazy For You: http://www.imagebam.com/gallery/yha2yht6731daasbk1hyimzgvrjbbmqa

[RUADJAI 14,909]

Vevo on the left?

 

And what are the best Videos to have? Ive been wanting to get them all and have no idea how I should get them......

[Fighter 28,797]

I dont bother with the vevo ones tbh.... 

[gb.bruck 63]

Vevo on the left?

 

And what are the best Videos to have? Ive been wanting to get them all and have no idea how I should get them......

 

I'm using the best ones that are available for free, if you want, i can share my encode of them with all the problems fixed ;)

And yeah, vevo on the left!

[madgefan 10,137]

Yesterday I played the Ciao Italia concert on my bluray player and got a bit sad because the quality of the image was shit